The Wakame Gatherers Mini-Unit
Lani Blechman, Fort River Elementary School Librarian, Amherst, MA
Robin Sindelar, Evanston Public Library, Evanston, IL
This mini-unit was developed at the Doors to the World 2017 Summer Institute sponsored by the Five College Center for East Asian Studies and funded by the Freeman Foundation.
Title: The Wakame Gatherers
Authors: Holly Thompson
Illustrator: Kazumi Wilds
Publisher: Shen’s Books, imprint of Lee and Low Books
Date of Publication: 2007
Genre(s): Realistic fiction
Summary:
When Nanami’s Gram from Maine visits Japan, Nanami’s Baachan (grandmother) takes them to the seashore to gather wakame seaweed. Seaweed turns out to be an object that connects both sides of her family, in spite of Nanami’s worries about the differences between her American and Japanese grandmothers.
About the author and illustrator:
Author Holly Thompson has lived for many years in Kamakura, Japan, where she raised her children, observed the harvesting of cultivated wakame, and gathered it with her children. Raised in New England, she earned her M.A. in fiction writing from New York University and now teaches creative writing at Yokohama City University. She writes for both children and adults and is the Regional Advisor of the Tokyo chapter of the Society of Children’s Book Writers and Illustrators. Her novel Ash is also set in Japan. More information about Holly Thompson is available on her website http://www.hatbooks.com/, as well as on her blog http://hatbooks.blogspot.com.
Illustrator Kazumi Wilds was born in Tokyo and studied art at the Women’s College of Art in Tokyo and at the University of Minnesota. While producing the pictures for The Wakame Gatherers, Wilds stayed with Thompson at her home in Kamakura. She sketched and took pictures of the places in the story while dialoguing with the author to find common understanding. After agreeing on a concept, the paintings were rendered in watercolor with airbrush effects. Kazumi Wilds is currently attending graduate school and studying Book Art. More information about her can be found on her website: https://wildskazumi-picturebook.jimdo.com/.
Sources of inspirations for the author and illustrator: As authors of this mini unit about The Wakame Gatherers, we were extremely fortunate to be able to meet the author of this book. Holly Thompson has lived in Kamakura, Japan for over 20 years and her love, appreciation, and comfort with the culture of Japan is obvious. Thompson showed us personal photographs of the wakame gathering beach depicted in the book, and photographs of the fisherwoman who was the model for the character Baachan.
Thompson made sure to include in her story the Japanese custom of purchasing seaweed from the fishing families on the beach when gathering your own. It is a sign of respect for the livelihood of the people who fish and process seaweed. These kinds of cultural details display Thompson’s deep knowledge of her subject matter and respect for the people of Japan. In addition, she has centered her story around a girl and her two grandmothers. The girl lives in Kamakura with her Japanese grandmother and her American grandmother from Maine comes to visit. Thompson has raised two American children in Japan and has personal experience of the themes the character Nanami examines in the book.
Kazumi Wilds has illustrated many English language books about Japan, and also many books in the Japanese language. Wilds is Japanese and has studied at the University of Minnesota, so she, like the author, has firsthand knowledge of both cultures depicted in this book. She told the author she wanted to get the pictures true to life, and visited the beach in Kamakura in order to depict it realistically. Thompson showed us a photograph of the woman used as a model for Baachan holding a copy of the book. The illustrator has certainly brought real world Kamakura to life!
Geographical region(s)/time period: 21st century, 1940s/WWII-era Kamakura, Japan
Cultural theme(s): Japanese culture, American-Maine culture, cross-cultural/family relationships, bicultural families, intergenerational relationships, celebrating identity, understanding family history, post-WWII healing and relationships, family and cultural relationships with food/natural resources, food cultivation and processing (seaweed), ethical tourism, acting as cultural guide, multilingual children, relationship of humans to water, comfort and healing.
Media of illustrations: Painting.
Awards and other recognitions: Notable Social Studies Trade Book for Young People
2009, National Council for the Social Studies (NCSS).
Other Curriculum Guides:
Lee and Low Books (https://www.leeandlow.com/uploads/loaded_document/385/The_Wakame_Gatherers_FINAL_Teacher_s_Guide_2017.pdf)
Program for Teaching East Asia (CO) (https://www.colorado.edu/cas/tea/curriculum/texts-and-contexts/two.html)
Hook Learning Experience—Wakame Experience
Objectives:
- Introduce the mini-unit with focus on object-based learning.
- Gain background knowledge about wakame through experiential learning.
- Introduce transformation and connection as two important themes in the book.
- Ask questions based on observations.
Activity:
Hand out dried wakame to each student without providing the name or any information about it.
Student instructions:
- OBSERVE. (You may want to look, touch, smell, or taste.)
- RECORD. (You may want to write, draw, or think.)
- What do you think you know about this?
- What do you observe?
- What do you wonder?
This is wakame. It is a seaweed, and it is an important object and symbol in The Wakame Gatherers. Part of what is important about it is how it connects people and ideas, and how it transforms.
Hand out a cup of warm water to each student and have them put what’s left of their wakame into the water. Give each a spoon in case they want to taste it after the warm water transforms it. (The wakame should expand, soften, and turn green.)
Student instructions:
- OBSERVE. (You may want to look, touch, smell, or taste.)
- RECORD. (You may want to write, draw, or think.)
- What do you think you know about this?
- What do you observe?
- What do you wonder?
We have watched the wakame transform, and in the book transformation (change) of feelings and ideas is important. Making connections with people is also important. So now you will make a connection.
Student instructions:
MAKE A CONNECTION: Find someone who made a similar observation.
Connecting Picture Book to Family, Community, and Current Events/People:
In this book we see a household where a grandmother lives with a nuclear family made up of two parents and two children.
- Is this common or uncommon in the United States? Is it common or uncommon in other parts of the world? Could living arrangements like these be normal for some groups in the United States and unusual for others?
- What would be the good things about having a grandmother live with the nuclear family?What would be uncomfortable about this?
- Where do older people in your family live? Where did older people in your family live 100 years ago?
- Did your parents live with their grandparents when they were growing up?
One striking thing about the topic of community in this book is the comparison of the two communities Baachan and Gram come from. The first page after the title page has illustrations of the two communities. Nan comes from Maine, and the illustration depicts a rocky seashore. There is a boat, an island covered with trees, but no people. In contrast, the seashore of Baachan’s town is gentle and sandy. There are people playing, a man walking with a surfboard and his dog, and a bustling street scene with streetcars and shops.
- Looking at the pictures of the beaches, how do they make you feel? Is it warm or cold in the picture?
- If you were to spend the day at the seashore in this picture, what would you be doing?Who would you see? Who would you talk to?
- Does this look like a rural area or an urban area?
- How would you get to and from the beach?How would you go food shopping in these places when you wanted something to go with the wakame?
- What would you hear or smell in these two places?
- How are the people connected?
This book has a two-page spread of Baachan’s experience during World War II in Japan. Against a black background, the top third of the page is filled with fire and a fighter plane. Baachan is shown as a child, huddled up with her big brother.
When we see the picture of the happy child collecting seaweed in the surf with her grandmothers, and on the next two pages see the picture representing wartime, we notice many differences.
- What differences can you see?
- How can you tell the war picture is from a long time ago?
- How do you think the children feel in the picture? What are the children doing?
- What can you hear and smell?
The picture after this one takes us back to the beautiful beach. When you look at this picture:
- How is it similar to the previous picture of the girl collecting seaweed? How is it different?
- What do the shapes of the grandmothers’ bodies tell you?
- Have you ever had to protect someone? Is there a group or someone in your family, neighborhood, or school in need of protection?
- Have you ever had to protect an idea? Which ideas would you fight to protect?
Somehow the beach is transformed by us knowing the horrible things that happened there before. The scene appears very ordinary—people having a lovely beach day—yet our protagonist is standing in the center of a triangle made by her two grandmothers. They are telling her to “always protect this peace”. Peace is something usually thought of as calm, as inaction, and here the grandmothers are giving the child a directive, a call to action. Protect the ordinary! Protect the everyday! The usual! The right of people to be able to wake up, to go to the beach, and enjoy the day without fear! The grandmothers are in a protective posture over Nanami during this exchange.
Reader’s Theater
Objectives:
- Use tableau to explore what Gram, Baachan, and Nanami feel while remembering and discussing WWII.
- Use tableau to understand what about daily life in Kamakura is both different and familiar.
Activity:
After reading the book using critical thinking and interactive methods such as Whole Book Approach and Visual Thinking Strategies, introduce the idea of “The Pacific Ocean theater”.
Ask students:
- What do you think you know about WWII?
- What do you think you know about the U.S. and Japan during WWII?
Turn and talk
Gram and Baachan were both children during WWII. We know that Baachan saw bombs, had to leave her home (with her brother), and lost her mother in WWII. We don’t know who else in her family was hurt by the war. We don’t know much about Gram’s experience with WWII, but because she lived in Maine we can assume that she did not see bombs fall on her home, and she probably did not have to leave her home. She may have seen lots of pictures and newspaper articles about the war, and she likely heard a lot on the radio. At school and at home, she probably had to practice what to do if bombs were dropped. Now they are two older women meeting each other for the first time.
Before they’ve met each other, how do you think they feel? What might they be thinking about?
Remember that they are grandmothers to the same child. Gram’s daughter and Baachan’s son live with Baachan and Nanami. Do you think this might change how Gram and Baachan feel about each other before they meet?
Read aloud and Tableaus
Together, we will read this book again. I ask you to think about how Baachan’s and Gram’s experiences during WWII affect them during the story. We will stop in the middle and use tableau (freezing our bodies and our faces into the positions of the people in the pictures) to explore these feelings and experiences more.
Stop during each of the following four spreads:
1. “I turn to Baachan. ‘Did you gather seaweed here when you were little?’”
2. “Then Baachan says, ‘Nanami-chan, senso no toki datta wa yo.’”
3. “‘I’m sorry,’ I finally say to one. ‘Gomen nasai,’ I say to the other.”
4. “Then Gram takes my hand and raises it high. ‘Daijobu!’ she shouts.”
Assign students to come up and take the pose and facial expression of each character appearing on the spread.
After everyone is settled into the scene and students in audience have a moment to look silently, invite students in the audience to ask questions of each character in the tableau. (Examples: How do you feel? Why are you doing what you’re doing? Do you see what’s going on with Baachan and Gram and Nanami?)
Note: If you include four Nanamis for the first spread and a dog for the third, then there are 21 total roles.
Finish reading the book. Ask students:
- What else did you learn about Baachan, Gram, or Nanami this time around?
Seaweed Learning Experience (an extension of the Hook Learning Experience)
Objectives:
- Identify seaweed as an ingredient used in food dishes.
- Recognize two parts of the world (Japan and US/Maine) where seaweed is used for food (and how), based on access to natural resources.
- Compare and contrast the farming methods of planting seeds in soil in the ground with growing spores in ropes in the ocean.
- Identify the three main parts of the wakame plant.
Seaweed Learning Experience Activities:
For an introduction to wakame science it is important to connect this plant used for food to plants the students use for food. The method used depends on the life experiences the students bring to the classroom. My own experience growing up in the Midwest did not include growing or using seaweed for consumption. As a teacher in a similar area, I would try to expand upon knowledge of local plants grown for food. Seaweed—wakame—is also a plant that is eaten, even if it is a bit different from the ones in our local gardens.
- The class could grow their own seeds in soil in clear cups, observing the roots of the plant digging down, and the shoots growing up.The students could do observational drawings or written observations of the plants.
- Share a diagram of the wakame plant (there is a good one at ala.org.au because wakame is an invasive species in Australia), and discuss the parts of the plant. Compare and contrast the wakame plant with the plants grown in the classroom. It would be very interesting to grow wakame in the classroom, however this plant grows in the ocean underwater.
The three main parts of the wakame plant are the blade (leaves), the stipe (stem), and the holdfast (the part of the plant that attaches in order for it to grow). Some seaweeds live and grow on top of the water, but wakame grows under the water. Wakame plants do not make seeds. Seeds contain an embryo of a plant surrounded by a nutrition source. Wakame produce spores, which are different in that they do not contain a food source for the young plant. When a plant reproduces using spores it is usual for the plant to produce many, many spores. Often they can withstand harsh conditions before finding a good place to grow.
Both wakame plants and the plants we grew in the classroom are green. The green color is from chlorophyll, the chemical both plants use for photosynthesis—the process of turning sunlight into energy for the plant to live and grow.
Have students write or draw their observations. A Venn diagram to compare and contrast could also work well here
- The following song can be sung to the tune of Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star.It’s to help remember the information about wakame:
Wakame, wakame, in the sea,
Reproduces sporically.
Little plants on ropes they grow,
Under water, down below.
Blade and stipe and holdfast too,
Tastes so good for me and you.
- After learning a bit about the plant itself, introduce the idea of local food to the students.Post photos around the classroom of different natural environments. Include forest, farm, oceanside, riverside, desert, and tundra. Give the students sticky notes to draw or write what they think people in these environments would be able to find for food. Have the students walk around the classroom and post their notes by the photos.
Discuss how people can live in all kinds of environments. The human body needs a certain number of calories per day to survive and certain vitamins and minerals. These environments look quite different but people get the nutrition they need in different ways. People in Maine and Japan use seaweed as a naturally grown and farmed plant to get the nutrition they need. Discuss the nutritional value of green plants and the amount of vegetables children are recommended to eat in one day (1.5 cups per day for 4-8 year olds).
As a wrap-up activity, have the students bring in an empty food box. Analyze the design of the box. With a partner or on their own, they will design a package for wakame. Drawing on knowledge from the lesson, they can create their own pretend wakame company to sell this food item. Will they be selling wakame to people for whom wakame is new or unusual, or to people already familiar with it? They can add slogans, drawings, or pictures of wakame, free recipes, or coupons to the box. They can also add nutritional information. This project would be best done on paper that is then affixed to the box after completion. The students could create a commercial to present to the class, or simply discuss their projects.
Themes: Family, bridging differences, acting as cultural guide
Questions to explore through object-based learning:
- What is your wakame?
- What is an object that represents how the people in your life love each other despite their differences?
- What is an object that connects you to your background or heritage, or to a place that’s important to you, or to family?
Day 1
Turn and talk:
- Why is wakame important to Baachan?
- Why is wakame important to Nanami?
- Why is wakame important to Gram?
Group discussion:
- How does wakame connect Baachan, Nanami, and Gram?
Make a drawing:
- What are some things in your life that connect you with people who are important to you, even when you’re different?
Explain your drawing to a partner:
- Who do these objects connect?
- How are you connected to these objects?
- What are the differences between the people that are connected by these objects? What are the similarities?
Day 2
Each student should bring in an object (or draw/print a picture of an object) that they decide is their wakame to share with the class. It can be one of the objects that they brainstormed during the drawing activity or anything else that they decide.
Gallery walk:
- Everyone in class can see all of the objects brought in.
Show and tell:
Done in small groups. The presenting student can choose to talk about any of the following:
- Who does this object connect?
- How are you connected to this object?
- What are the differences between the people that are connected by this object?
- What are the similarities?
- Why is this object important to you?
2017 Massachusetts English Language Arts and Literacy Curriculum Framework
Guiding Principles for English Language Arts and Literacy Programs
- Guiding Principle 6: Students should have frequent opportunities for discussing and writing about their readings in order to develop critical thinking skills and to demonstrate understanding.
- Guiding Principle 10: Social and emotional learning can increase academic achievement, improve attitudes and behaviors, and reduce emotional distress. Students should practice recognizing aspects of themselves in texts (self-awareness), struggling productively with challenging texts (self-management), tailoring language to audience and purpose
(social awareness), grappling vicariously with choices faced by others (responsible decision making), and collaborating respectfully with diverse peers (relationship skills). - Guiding Principle 11: Educators should select works of fiction and nonfiction that instill in students a deep appreciation for art, beauty, and truth, while broadening their understanding of the human condition from differing points of view. Reading, discussing, and writing about high-quality prose and poetry should also help students develop empathy for one another and a sense of their shared values and literary heritage, while learning about who they are as individuals and developing the capacity for independent, rigorous thinking.
College and Career Readiness Anchor Standards for Reading
Key Ideas and Details:
- 3. Analyze how and why individuals, events, and ideas develop and interact over the course of a text.
Craft and Structure:
- 6. Assess how point of view or purpose shapes the content and style of a text.
College and Career Readiness Anchor Standards for Speaking and Listening
Comprehension and Collaboration:
- Prepare for and participate effectively in a range of conversations and collaborations with diverse partners, building on others’ ideas and expressing their own clearly and persuasively.
- Evaluate a speaker’s point of view, reasoning, and use of evidence and rhetoric.
College and Career Readiness Anchor Standards for Language
Vocabulary Acquisition and Use:
- 4. Determine or clarify the meaning of unknown and multiple-meaning words and phrases by using context clues, analyzing meaningful word parts, and consulting general and specialized reference materials, as appropriate.
2016 Massachusetts Science and Technology/Engineering Curriculum Framework
Grades Pre-K–2: Overview of Science and Engineering Practices
- Raise questions about how different types of environments provide homes for living things; ask and/or identify questions that can be answered by an investigation.
Grades 3–5: Overview of Science and Engineering Practices
- 7. Construct an argument that animals and plants have internal and external structures that support their survival, growth, behavior, and reproduction; distinguish among facts, reasoned judgment based on data, and speculation in an argument.
- 8. Obtain and summarize information about the climate of different regions; gather information on possible solutions to a given design problem; obtain information about renewable and nonrenewable energy sources.
Pre-K-3: Life Science
LS1. From Molecules to Organisms: Structures and Processes
- PreK-LS1-1(MA). Compare, using descriptions and drawings, the external body parts of animals (including humans) and plants and explain functions of some of the observable body parts.
- K-LS1-1. Observe and communicate that animals (including humans) and plants need food, water, and air to survive. Animals get food from plants or other animals. Plants make their own food and need light to live and grow.
- K-LS1-2(MA). Recognize that all plants and animals grow and change over time.
- 1-LS1-1. Use evidence to explain that (a) different animals use their body parts and senses in different ways to see, hear, grasp objects, protect themselves, move from place to place, and seek, find, and take in food, water, and air, and (b) plants have roots,
stems, leaves, flowers, and fruits that are used to take in water, air, and other nutrients, and produce food for the plant. - 3-LS1-1. Use simple graphical representations to show that different types of organisms have unique and diverse life cycles. Describe that all organisms have birth, growth,
reproduction, and death in common but there are a variety of ways in which these
happen.
LS3. Heredity: Inheritance and Variation of Traits
- 1-LS3-1. Use information from observations (first-hand and from media) to identify similarities and differences among individual plants or animals of the same kind.
LS4. Biological Evolution: Unity and Diversity
2-LS4-1. Use texts, media, or local environments to observe and compare (a) different kinds of living things in an area, and (b) differences in the kinds of living things living in
different types of areas.